Butterscotch Cookies Crispy, crunchy butterscotch cookies made with brown sugar and browned butter. Perfect for dipping! Butterscotch Pudding Rich and creamy old fashioned butterscotch pudding, made with butter, brown sugar, cream, milk, and egg yolks. How to Make Butterscotch When was the last time you tasted authentic butterscotch? A classic butterscotch sauce recipe with brown sugar, butter, and cream. Magic Bars Classic 7-layer magic bars with chocolate, nuts, butterscotch, and coconut! They're the perfect make-ahead dessert for your next party.